• Home
  • About Us
  • Contributor’s Biogs
    • Falcon Chambers (Barristers)
      • Contact Falcon Chambers
      • Kirk Reynolds QC
      • Guy Fetherstonhaugh QC
      • Stephen Jourdan QC
      • Janet Bignell QC
    • Milton McIntosh (Solicitor)
      • Contact
    • Alex Charlesworth FRICS (Building Surveyor)
      • Contact
    • Edward Shaw MRICS (Building Surveyor)
      • Contact
    • Peter Beckett FRICS (Valuation Surveyor)
      • Contact
    • Richard Kay FRICS (Valuation Surveyor)
      • Contact

Dilapidations

Occupier and Invester Facing Dilapidations Advice From The Specialists

  • News
  • Office
  • Industrial
  • Retail
  • Investor
  • Occupier
  • Legal
You are here: Home / Sectors / Investor / Can Empty Rates be Avoided During Refurbishment Works?

Can Empty Rates be Avoided During Refurbishment Works?

March 19, 2015 By Milton McIntosh Leave a Comment

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

empty_ratesIn a case concerning liability to empty rates the Court of Appeal found that an office in the middle of a scheme of refurbishment and not actually fit for occupation still attracted a rates liability.

S J & J Monk v Newbigin (VO) (2015) concerned an office building in Sunderland.  At the relevant valuation date of 6 January 2012, the building was being refurbished.  The suspended ceiling, half the raised floor, the cooling system, sanitary fittings and electrical wiring had all been stripped out and a limited amount of partitioning and electrical replacement work to the WCs had been undertaken.  The building owner argued that the space was incapable of beneficial occupation as offices due to its actual physical state and should have a nominal rateable value.

The Upper Tribunal agreed.  However, the Court of Appeal disagreed.  It said that the property should be valued as it stood on the valuation date, rebus sic stantibus, but pointed to the Local Government Finance Act 1988 which provides that, in assessing the rateable value of premises, it is to be assumed that the premises are “in a state of reasonable repair, but exclude from this assumption any repairs which a reasonable landlord would consider uneconomic.”

The Court said that common law applied, that repair was the converse of disrepair and that a state of disrepair connoted a deterioration from some previous physical condition.  If it could be shown that the property was worse than it had been at some earlier time, it did not matter whether the deterioration had been deliberate or otherwise.  The offices were in a worse condition than at some earlier time and could be said to be in disrepair.

Further, in order to decide whether works needed were works of repair fairly so called, it was necessary, the Court said, to compare the premises in their actual state with their previous state, and it considered the case of Lurcott v Wakely (1911) in which it was said that “[repair] is restoration by renewal or replacement of subsidiary parts of a whole [whilst renewal, in contrast] … is reconstruction of the entirety, meaning by the entirety not necessarily the whole but substantially the whole subject-matter under discussion.”

Applying Lurcott, the Court found that the works were repairs.  The original Tribunal had found on the facts that the offices could be put back into their former state economically.  Thus the repair works were not excluded under the 1988 Act, and so the statutory assumption of repair applied making the offices liable to a substantive rating assessment

Milton McIntosh

Milton is a Consultant Property Litigation Solicitor with Excello Law. Milton deals with all aspects of real estate disputes, including the full range of landlord and tenant matters. Milton has particular expertise in dilapidations, being a former member of the RICS Dilapidations Working Group and involved in the writing of previous editions of the RICS Guidance Note on Dilapidations. Milton advises clients and writes regularly on the area of dilapidations.

LinkedIn Skype    

  • Investor
  • Occupier
  • Office
  • Industrial
  • Retail

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

In association with;

In association with;

Most Searched For Topics

ADR (Appropriate Dispute Resolution) arbitration break clause Building Surveyor chattel Claim for Damages claims complex Contact court cases covenant; dilapidations; diminution; disrepair; landlord; leasehold; refurbish; repair; reversion; tenant; valuation demise dilapidations dilapidations advice dilapidations definition diminution valuation disrepair early neutral evaluation Empty Rates expert determination fixture fixtures intention interim schedule lease liability legal litigation mediation negotiation negotiations planned maintenance practical dilaps pre-action protocol procedures quantified demand repair schedule of condition scott schedule settlements terminal schedule The Experts vacant possession valuation valuation surveyor What is Dilapidations?
  • Dispute Resolution: A review of the RICS Dilapidations Scheme

    [caption id="attachment_1252" align="alignright" width="300"] Click here to download a PDF copy of the full article[/caption] Dispute Resolution: A review of the RICS Dilapidations Scheme for Expert Determination (This article first appeared in the Journal of Building Survey, Appraisal & Valuation Volume

  • Diminution Valuation Simplified

    [caption id="attachment_1240" align="alignright" width="240"] Click to Download PDF Article[/caption] This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here,

  • Break Clause Conditions – A Legal Minefield

    Operating a break clause is not simply a case of submitting a formal notice to terminate the lease in accordance with the break clause conditions. This is far from the case, and the devil is in the detail. Break clauses

  • Tenant Guide to Landlord Disrepair Claims

    The expiry of a lease presents a landlord with the possibility of an income void lasting many months, which has an even greater impact in a difficult lettings market. It is unsurprising, therefore, that unscrupulous landlords sometimes regard a terminal

  • Diminution valuation in dilapidations cases

    Critique of the "Stand In The Street" method - in contrast to the Shortlands residual valuation method THE CRUDE "STAND IN THE STREET" METHOD This method is dying out gradually.  It consists of looking at the building without analysis of

  • ADR
  • Articles
  • Break Clause
  • Exit Strategy
  • Industrial
  • Investor
  • legal
  • Mechanical & Electrical
  • Negotiations
  • Office
  • Negotiations
  • Occupier
  • Practice & Procedures
  • Retail
  • Terminology
  • Top Tips
  • Vacant Possession
  • Valuation
  • Dilapidations Protocol

Copyright AC Website Design© 2023·Built By AC Website Design ·Log in