• Home
  • About Us
  • Contributor’s Biogs
    • Falcon Chambers (Barristers)
      • Contact Falcon Chambers
      • Kirk Reynolds QC
      • Guy Fetherstonhaugh QC
      • Stephen Jourdan QC
      • Janet Bignell QC
    • Milton McIntosh (Solicitor)
      • Contact
    • Alex Charlesworth FRICS (Building Surveyor)
      • Contact
    • Edward Shaw MRICS (Building Surveyor)
      • Contact
    • Peter Beckett FRICS (Valuation Surveyor)
      • Contact
    • Richard Kay FRICS (Valuation Surveyor)
      • Contact

Dilapidations

Occupier and Invester Facing Dilapidations Advice From The Specialists

Can we help?
Close
Your Name
Your Email
Enter Your Message

  • News
  • Office
  • Industrial
  • Retail
  • Investor
  • Occupier
  • Legal
You are here: Home / Sectors / Investor / Head tenant held liable for disrepairs outside demise

Head tenant held liable for disrepairs outside demise

March 19, 2015 By Milton McIntosh Leave a Comment

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

liabilityA residential long leaseholder may be liable without notice to his subtenant under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 for disrepairs to communal areas outside his demise by virtue of having a right over those areas.

In Edwards v Kumarasamy (2015) Mr K was the long leaseholder of a flat in a residential block.  Mr K’s lease gave him the right to use the block’s communal hall, pathway and other facilities.  The freeholder of the block covenanted to keep the communal areas in good repair but its liability was restricted to cases in which it had notice of the defects and failed the remedy the defects.  Mr K rented the flat to Mr E under an assured shorthold tenancy.  One evening, Mr E tripped oven an uneven paving stone on the communal pathway and was injured.  He was awarded damages against Mr K.

The question arose on appeal whether section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 was of application to the situation.  Section 11 implied into the tenancy an obligation on Mr K “to keep in repair the structure and exterior of the dwellinghouse … [and of] … any part of the building in which the lessor has an estate or interest.”  Mr K argued that section 11 did apply to the external communal pathway since it was neither part of the “dwellinghouse”, i.e., the area demised to Mr E under the AST, nor part of a “building”.  He further argued that his liability was conditional upon notice of the disrepairs and no such notice had been given to him by Mr E.

The Court of Appeal disagreed.  It said that Mr K’s right to use the communal path was a legal easement and therefore he had an estate or interest.  The path was not part of the building but it was, the Court said, part of the exterior of the building, and it relied upon the decision of Brown v Liverpool Corp (1983) in which steps up to a front door were held to be part of the exterior of a dwelling.

As for the notice argument, the Court said that the general rule was that a covenant to repair obliged a landlord to keep in repair at all times, so there was a breach immediately a defect occurred but that there was an exception where the defect occurred in the demised premises themselves, in which case the landlord would be in breach only when it had information about the existence of the defect such as would put a reasonable landlord on inquiry as to whether works of repair were needed and it failed to do the necessary works with reasonable expedition.  The same approach was to be applied to the statutory covenant implied by section 11 and, in any event, the qualification about notice was not expressed in the statutory covenant.  As the defect was outside Mr E’s demise, no notice condition applied and Mr K was liable for Mr E’s injury

Milton McIntosh

Milton is a Consultant Property Litigation Solicitor with Excello Law. Milton deals with all aspects of real estate disputes, including the full range of landlord and tenant matters. Milton has particular expertise in dilapidations, being a former member of the RICS Dilapidations Working Group and involved in the writing of previous editions of the RICS Guidance Note on Dilapidations. Milton advises clients and writes regularly on the area of dilapidations.

LinkedIn Skype    

  • Investor
  • Occupier
  • Office
  • Industrial
  • Retail

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Diminution Valuation Simplified

LinkedIn0
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
Pinterest0

This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here, or by clicking the image; A landlord claims against a tenant in dilapidations.  The building surveyors agree everything at the Contractual Claim level, but […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

In association with;

In association with;

Most Searched For Topics

ADR (Appropriate Dispute Resolution) break clause Building Surveyor chattel Claim for Damages claims complex Contact contract administration court cases covenant; dilapidations; diminution; disrepair; landlord; leasehold; refurbish; repair; reversion; tenant; valuation demise dilapidations advice dilapidations assessment dilapidations definition Dilapidations Specialist diminution valuation disrepair Empty Rates fixture fixtures intention interim schedule lease liability legal litigation negotiations planned maintenance practical dilaps pre-action protocol procedures Proudfoot V's Hart quantified demand remove chattel remove fixtures repair schedule of condition scott schedule settlements terminal schedule The Experts vacant possession valuation valuation surveyor What is Dilapidations?
  • Dispute Resolution: A review of the RICS Dilapidations Scheme

    [caption id="attachment_1252" align="alignright" width="300"] Click here to download a PDF copy of the full article[/caption] Dispute Resolution: A review of the RICS Dilapidations Scheme for Expert Determination (This article first appeared in the Journal of Building Survey, Appraisal & Valuation Volume

  • Diminution Valuation Simplified

    [caption id="attachment_1240" align="alignright" width="240"] Click to Download PDF Article[/caption] This is about how a diminution valuation simplified using an imaginary claim with only one effective difference between the parties. A pdf of the full article can be downloaded from here,

  • Break Clause Conditions – A Legal Minefield

    Operating a break clause is not simply a case of submitting a formal notice to terminate the lease in accordance with the break clause conditions. This is far from the case, and the devil is in the detail. Break clauses

  • Tenant Guide to Landlord Disrepair Claims

    The expiry of a lease presents a landlord with the possibility of an income void lasting many months, which has an even greater impact in a difficult lettings market. It is unsurprising, therefore, that unscrupulous landlords sometimes regard a terminal

  • Diminution valuation in dilapidations cases

    Critique of the "Stand In The Street" method - in contrast to the Shortlands residual valuation method THE CRUDE "STAND IN THE STREET" METHOD This method is dying out gradually.  It consists of looking at the building without analysis of

  • ADR
  • Articles
  • Break Clause
  • Exit Strategy
  • Industrial
  • Investor
  • legal
  • Mechanical & Electrical
  • Negotiations
  • Office
  • Negotiations
  • Occupier
  • Practice & Procedures
  • Retail
  • Terminology
  • Top Tips
  • Vacant Possession
  • Valuation
  • Dilapidations Protocol

Copyright AC Website Design© 2022·Built By AC Website Design ·Log in